Beanie Babies were a popular toy in the 1990s and early 2000s, with collectors paying high prices for rare and limited edition versions. While the craze has died down, there are still collectors and enthusiasts looking to buy and sell these stuffed animals.
So if you have a collection of Beanie Babies that you no longer want or need, you may be wondering where to sell them for the best price. Fortunately, there are several options available for selling Beanie Babies.
One of the most popular options is online marketplaces like eBay, where you can list your items for sale and reach a large audience of potential buyers. However, there are also other online marketplaces and physical stores that specialize in collectibles and may be interested in purchasing your Beanie Babies.
In this article, I’ll explore some of the best places to sell Beanie Babies for the most money. I’ll cover online marketplaces, collectible stores, pawn shops, and more.
Whether you have a few rare Beanie Babies or a large collection, I’ll help you find the best place to sell them and get the most cash in your pocket.
Where to Sell Beanie Babies?
1. eBay
eBay is one of the most popular online marketplaces to sell Beanie Babies. It allows you to sell worldwide and even auction your collectibles to the highest bidder.
To get started, create an account and search for the name of the Beanie Baby that you want to sell along with which generation it belongs to. Select the “Sold” option on the left side of the window so you can see the prices that the Beanie Baby sold for recently.
Check the past 3-4 months to get an idea of how many people are selling it and how much they got for it.
When creating your listing, make sure to include clear and detailed photos of your Beanie Baby, along with a description of its condition and any other relevant details. Set a reasonable price and be prepared to negotiate with potential buyers.
2. Etsy
Etsy is another popular online marketplace for selling Beanie Babies. It attracts people with the “nostalgia” factor, so there’s no shortage of interested buyers.
Similar to eBay, your first steps will be to create an account and list your Beanie Baby along with clear photos and a detailed description of its condition.
It’s also worth doing some research into the best keywords to use so that people can easily find your listings.
Related: 23 Best Things to Sell on Etsy to Make Money
3. Sell2BBNovelties
Want to sell your Beanie Babies but don’t want to deal with auction sites or listing fees? Sell2BBNovelties might be the perfect solution for you!
Sell2BBNovelties is an online store that buys products from collectors. And right now, they’re looking for Beanie Babies!
The best part? They cover shipping charges if you have over $30 worth of toys to sell. And unlike other platforms, they don’t charge selling fees! You can sell your items individually or in bulk, and you don’t have to worry about auctions ending too low.
Sell2BBNovelties sells Beanie Babies to other collectors, wholesalers, or stores, and they may even donate some. So you know your collection is going to a good home.
All you need to do is search for your Beanie Babies using their Lookup Library, add them to your sell order, and make sure they’re in mint condition. If your sell order reaches $30 or more, you can ship for free!
4. Antique Stores
Antique stores are a great place to sell rare and valuable Beanie Babies. They have a wide network of collectors and enthusiasts who are willing to pay top dollar for unique items.
To find antique stores near you, do a quick online search or ask around for recommendations. Make sure to bring your Beanie Baby in for an appraisal before selling it to ensure you get a fair price.
5. Collectible Stores
Collectible stores specialize in buying and selling all types of collectibles like baseball cards and Beanie Babies. They have a good understanding of the market and can offer fair prices for your items.
Much like antique stores, start your search for collectible stores near you by doing a quick online search or ask around for recommendations. They’ll likely also ask you to bring your Beanie Baby in for an appraisal before selling it so you’ll at least have a rough idea of what you should get for it.
6. Flea Markets
Flea markets are a great place to sell Beanie Babies, especially if you have a large collection to sell. They offer a fun and casual atmosphere where you can interact with potential buyers and negotiate prices.
Flea markets are often advertised on local Facebook groups, but the old wall of fliers on the wall at the supermarket could also link you up with the next one.
When you’re there, make sure to set up an eye-catching display and have clear prices for each item.
You may also be interested in: 31 Best Things to Sell at a Farmers Market
7. Craigslist
Craigslist is a popular online marketplace and is easily one of the best sites to sell things locally, including being a great place where you can sell Beanie Babies locally. It’s free to post your listing and you can reach a large audience in your area.
Simply create an account and post your Beanie Baby along with clear photos and a detailed description of its condition. Be prepared to negotiate with potential buyers and always meet up in a public place to complete the transaction to be safe.
8. Pawn Shops
Pawn shops are a good option if you need quick cash for your Beanie Babies. They offer cash on the spot for your items, but the price may be lower than what you would get from other selling options.
You should be able to find pawn shops near you from a quick Google Maps search, which also has the added benefit of giving you reviews on whether the shop is legit or not.
9. Bonanza
Bonanza is a great online marketplace with a high rating on the Apple App Store. It’s super easy to use and lets you sell almost anything, including your beloved Beanie Babies.
The best part? Bonanza charges lower fees than other online options, like eBay. You only pay $0.25 for each item you sell and a 3.5% final value fee. That means more money in your pocket!
Another cool feature of Bonanza is that you can use the same listings you have on other platforms, like eBay or Amazon, and integrate them into the Bonanza platform. It’s a great way to diversify your options and reach more buyers.
Just remember, if you sell on Bonanza, you’re responsible for shipping the items to the buyer. So be sure to include the shipping cost in your prices to ensure you don’t lose money.
10. PlushCollector.com
PlushCollector.com is another platform that lets you sell Pokemon cards or your Beanie Babies without the hassle of listing or auction fees.
All you need to do is register on the site and let them know what you have. If they’re interested in buying, they’ll offer you a quote, and you can accept or deny it. If you accept, you’ll ship your items to them for confirmation.
Once confirmed, they’ll process your payment within five business days via PayPal or check.
PlushCollector.com doesn’t offer a minimum payout like Sell2BBNovelties, but they’re not as strict about the condition of your items.
To sell your Beanie Babies on PlushCollector.com, just search for your items on their website, click “Add to Quote,” and wait for a sales associate to contact you.
They’ll provide you with the steps to ship your items, check the condition and authenticity of your items, and pay you within one week. Plus, they cover shipping for orders over $25!
Find out more about: 7 Best Websites to Sell Stuff Locally and Make Quick Cash
11. Sell4Value
Sell4Value is a retailer that accepts orders through an order form on their website. Although their website seems outdated, they’re still accepting orders, and you can get a quote by filling out the form.
While they’re picky about what they accept, it’s worth checking their list to see if you have any of the ones mentioned. Who knows, you may end up with some extra cash in your pocket!
12. Facebook Marketplace
If you’re looking for a free and easy way to sell your Beanie Babies, consider Facebook Marketplace!
While it’s true that you’ll only be targeting a local audience, it’s worth a shot. Just post what you have and see if you get any bites. If not, you can always take the listings down or ignore them.
Keep in mind that you’ll likely have to meet in person, so if you’re uneasy about this, it might not be the best option for you. But if you take some standard precautions, like meeting in a public place and bringing someone with you or telling someone where you’re going, it should be fine.
13. Facebook Groups
If you’re looking for a targeted audience to sell your Beanie Babies, Facebook Groups might be the perfect solution for you!
There are plenty of Facebook Groups dedicated to buying, selling, or trading Beanie Babies. Just make sure the group is active before you join, so you don’t waste your time creating a post.
Joining a group is easy – just search for the one you’re interested in, post what you have, and work out a deal with anyone who responds. Just remember to read the rules before posting to make sure you get your post approved.
14. Ruby Lane
If you have vintage Beanie Babies, Ruby Lane might be the best place to sell them. Ruby Lane is an online store that specializes in quality vintage goods, and Ty Warner creations now fit that bill.
Many of the stuffed toys sell in the range of $30-50 each on Ruby Lane, with some reaching prices as high as $75. The patina of an antique plush toy and a discerning audience might make Ruby Lane the perfect place to get the best value for your Ty Beanie Baby collection.
15. VarageSale
VarageSale is an online marketplace where you can sell your Beanie Babies without any hassle.
All you need to do is create an account and link your Facebook profile to verify your identity. Once done, you can easily create a listing for your items – it’s completely free!
When your Beanie Babies get a potential buyer, you’ll receive a notification. From there, you can chat with them to set up a meeting. After finalizing the transaction, don’t forget to set your listing to “Reserve.”
The next step is to meet your buyer, complete the sale, and receive your payment. And make sure to mark your Beanie Babies as sold and leave your customer a review. It’s that easy and convenient!
Can you make money from selling Beanie Babies?
Although the Beanie Babies craze may have died down, collectors are still on the lookout for rare and vintage items to add to their collections. This means that you can still make money from selling Beanie Babies, although it’s not a guaranteed source of income.
Basically, it depends on a few factors. If you have rare or retired Beanie Babies in good condition, there may be collectors willing to pay a high price for them.
However, it’s important to do your research and price your Beanie Babies appropriately to attract potential buyers.
There are plenty of online marketplaces, such as Bonanza and Sell2BBNovelties, where you can sell your Beanie Babies. And with the convenience of the internet, it’s never been easier to connect with potential buyers from all over the world.
But don’t just stop at online marketplaces – consider selling on Facebook Groups, Ruby Lane, or even at local garage sales. You never know who might be interested in buying your Beanie Babies.
In brief, whether you’re looking to make extra money or just want to clear out some space in your home, selling your Beanie Babies is a great way to do it.
Do any Beanie Babies have any value?
While not all Beanie Babies are valuable, some rare and retired ones can fetch a high price. For example, a first-generation Peanut the Elephant Beanie Baby sold for $3,000 on eBay in 2018.
However, just because a Beanie Baby is retired doesn’t mean it’s valuable. The condition and rarity of the specific Beanie Baby are important factors to consider.
Find out more about: 19 Easy Methods to Make Quick Cash for the Holidays
Does anyone buy Beanie Babies anymore?
Yes, there are still collectors who buy Beanie Babies. However, the market is not as strong as it was in the 90s. Some collectors may only be interested in specific Beanie Babies, while others may be willing to buy any rare or retired ones they come across.
It’s important to do your research and price your Beanie Babies appropriately to attract potential buyers.
Which Beanie Babies are worth selling?
Beanie Babies were a popular collector’s item in the 1990s, and some rare or highly sought-after versions can still be valuable today. Here are a few Beanie Babies that may be worth selling:
- Princess the Bear: This purple bear was created in honor of Princess Diana and was produced in limited quantities. It can be worth thousands of dollars in good condition.
- Peace Bear: This tie-dyed bear was also produced in limited quantities and is highly sought after by collectors. It can be worth several hundred to several thousand dollars, depending on condition.
- Claude the Crab: This bright red crab was a limited edition Beanie Baby and can be worth several hundred dollars in good condition.
- Snort the Bull: This Beanie Baby was retired relatively early and can be worth several hundred dollars in good condition.
- Valentino the Bear: This white bear with a red heart on its chest was produced in limited quantities and can be worth several hundred to several thousand dollars, depending on condition.
- Curly the Bear: This brown bear with curly fur was produced in limited quantities and can be worth several hundred dollars in good condition.
It’s important to note that the value of Beanie Babies can vary widely depending on condition, rarity, and demand among collectors. Before selling any Beanie Babies, it’s a good idea to do some research and consult with a reputable appraiser or collector to determine their value.
How do I know if my Ty Beanie Baby is worth money?
If you’re looking to sell your Beanie Babies, it’s important to know which ones are worth money. Not every Beanie Baby is valuable, so it’s important to do your research before listing them for sale. Here are some things to look for:
- Rarity: The rarer the Beanie Baby, the more valuable it is likely to be. Some Beanie Babies were only produced for a short time, making them harder to find.
- Errors: Beanie Babies with manufacturing errors can be worth more than those without. For example, a Beanie Baby with a misspelled name or a wrong date on its tag could be worth more.
- Condition: Beanie Babies in mint condition are worth more than those that have been played with or have visible wear and tear.
Keep in mind that just because a Beanie Baby is old, it doesn’t necessarily mean it’s worth a lot of money. Some of the most valuable Beanie Babies were produced in the late 1990s and early 2000s, while others from that same time period are worth very little.
You may also be interested in: 40 Easy Ways to Make $20 Instantly Now (Fast and Free)
How do I know what to sell my Beanie Babies for?
Once you’ve determined which Beanie Babies are worth selling, the next step is to figure out how much to sell them for. Here are some tips:
- Research: Look at what similar Beanie Babies are selling for on sites like eBay and Etsy. This will give you an idea of what price range to aim for.
- Condition: Beanie Babies in better condition are worth more, so take that into account when pricing your items.
- Bundle: If you have multiple Beanie Babies that aren’t worth a lot individually, consider bundling them together to increase their value.
Remember that the market for Beanie Babies can fluctuate, so what they’re worth today might not be what they’re worth tomorrow. Keep an eye on prices and adjust your prices accordingly to ensure you’re getting the best value for your Beanie Babies.
How much does it cost to authenticate a Beanie Baby?
As a Beanie Baby collector, you know that authenticity is everything. But how much does it cost to authenticate a Beanie Baby? The answer depends on the service you choose and the level of authentication you need. Here are some options:
| Service | Cost | Description |
| True Blue Beans Economy Service | $5.00 per Beanie Baby | Their Economy service involves them processing your Beanie by placing it in a zip lock style bag with a sticker that states “authentic” or “counterfeit”. The customer is responsible for shipping to True Blue Beans. Return shipping will be calculated at check-out. |
| Peggy Gallagher Enterprises, Inc. | Varies | Prices vary depending on the type of Beanie Baby and the level of authentication needed. The company offers Platinum, Asia, and Standard forms of authentication, with corresponding prices. |
It’s important to note that some appraisers or authentication services may charge more for rare or valuable Beanie Babies. It’s always a good idea to do your research and compare prices before choosing a service.
While it may be tempting to go for the cheapest option, remember that authenticity is key when it comes to Beanie Babies. Investing in a reputable and thorough authentication service can help protect your investment and give you peace of mind.
Where to sell Beanie Babies for cash
1. Facebook Marketplace
Facebook Marketplace is a free platform for buying and selling items within your local community. It’s a great option if you prefer to sell your Beanie Babies locally and avoid shipping costs.
You can create a listing for your Beanie Babies and set your own price, and interested buyers can contact you directly through Facebook Messenger.
Keep in mind that Facebook Marketplace has a lower reach compared to eBay and Etsy, so it may take longer to find a buyer.
Related: 25 Best Selling Items on OfferUp in 2023 (to Make Great Money)
2. Craigslist
Craigslist is another free platform for buying and selling items locally. It’s similar to Facebook Marketplace, but with a less user-friendly interface. You can create a listing for your Beanie Babies and set your own price, and interested buyers can contact you directly through email or phone.
Like Facebook Marketplace, Craigslist has a lower reach compared to eBay and Etsy, so it may take longer to find a buyer.
3. Pawn Shops
If you need cash quickly and don’t mind selling your Beanie Babies for less than their market value, pawn shops can be an option. Pawn shops will typically offer you a lower price for your Beanie Babies than what you could get on eBay or Etsy, but you’ll get cash on the spot. Keep in mind that you’ll need to negotiate with the pawn shop owner to get the best price for your Beanie Babies.
Overall, there are many options for selling your Beanie Babies for cash, including online marketplaces like eBay and Etsy, local platforms like Facebook Marketplace and Craigslist, and pawn shops.
Consider your goals and pricing strategy when choosing where to sell your Beanie Babies.
Tips for selling Beanie Babies
Are you ready to sell your Beanie Babies but not sure where to start? Here are some tips to help you get the most out of your sale:
- Take clear and detailed photos: When selling online, photos are everything. Take pictures of your Beanie Baby from multiple angles and in good lighting to show its condition. Make sure to capture any flaws or imperfections as well.
- Price competitively: Do some research on similar Beanie Babies to get an idea of their value. Price your Beanie Baby competitively to attract potential buyers. Don’t forget to factor in any fees or shipping costs.
- Provide a detailed description: Along with your photos, provide a detailed description of your Beanie Baby. Include information such as its name, condition, and any special tags or features. The more information you provide, the more likely you are to make a sale.
- Consider selling in bundles: If you have multiple Beanie Babies to sell, consider bundling them together. This can be a great way to attract buyers who are looking for a collection.
- Choose the right selling platform: There are many different places to sell Beanie Babies, from online marketplaces like eBay and Etsy to local antique stores and collectible shops. Choose the platform that best fits your needs and target audience.
By following these tips, you can increase your chances of selling your Beanie Babies quickly and for a good price. Happy selling!
What are the best times to sell Beanie Babies?
If you want to make the most money selling your Beanie Babies, it’s important to know when the best time to sell them is. Here are a few tips:
- Sell during the holiday season: Many people are looking for unique and nostalgic gifts during the holiday season, so this is a great time to sell your Beanie Babies.
- Sell during the summer: Summer is a popular time for flea markets and garage sales, so if you’re planning on selling your Beanie Babies in person, this is a great time to do it.
- Sell during special events: If there’s a collectibles convention or other special event happening in your area, consider selling your Beanie Babies there. You’ll be able to connect with other collectors and potentially make more money.
It’s also important to keep an eye on current trends and popular Beanie Baby releases. If there’s a new release or a particular Beanie Baby that’s in high demand, it’s a good idea to sell it while the hype is still strong.
Remember, the value of Beanie Babies can fluctuate over time, so it’s important to do your research and stay up-to-date on current market trends. By selling at the right time and staying informed, you can maximize your profits and make the most out of your Beanie Baby collection.
